2016

Matt's

  1. Moonlight
  2. Sing Street
  3. Arrival
  4. The Witch
  5. Loving
  6. Hell or High Water
  7. Krisha
  8. Manchester by the Sea
  9. American Honey
  10. Rogue One: A Star Wars Story

Runners-up: Other People, Toni Erdmann, Embrace of the Serpent

Nathan's

  1. Moonlight
  2. Cameraperson
  3. Other People
  4. Arrival
  5. The Handmaiden
  6. 20th Century Women
  7. Jackie
  8. American Honey
  9. Lion
  10. Sing Street

Runners-up: A Bigger Splash, Fences, Maggie's Plan, The Fits


2015

Nathan's

  1. The Look of Silence
  2. Mad Max: Fury Road
  3. 45 Years
  4. Sicario
  5. Nasty Baby
  6. Carol
  7. Kumiko, the Treasure Hunter
  8. Spotlight
  9. Everything Will Be Okay (Alles Wird Gut)
  10. Amy

Runners-up: Clouds of Sils Maria, Son of Saul, Inside Out

Matt's

  1. Spotlight
  2. Carol
  3. Mad Max: Fury Road
  4. 45 Years
  5. Room
  6. Mustang
  7. Brooklyn
  8. Wild Tales
  9. It Follows
  10. Ex Machina

Runners-up: Phoenix, Sicario, Amy


2014

2014best-boyhood.jpg
2014best-selma2.jpg

Matt's

  1. Boyhood
  2. Selma
  3. Wild
  4. Pride
  5. Ida
  6. The Grand Budapest Hotel
  7. Force Majeure
  8. Foxcatcher
  9. Mommy
  10. The Way He Looks

Runners-up: Stranger by the LakeThe Babadook, Birdman, G.B.F.

Nathan's

  1. Ida
  2. Under the Skin
  3. Gloria
  4. Birdman
  5. Boyhood
  6. Wild
  7. Snowpiercer
  8. Pride
  9. Selma
  10. (tie) Citizenfour and Interstellar

Runners-up: Mr. Turner, The Skeleton Twins, Le Week-End


2013

francesha
gravitytopten
beforemidnight

Matt's

  1. Gravity
  2. Before Midnight
  3. Frances Ha
  4. 12 Years a Slave
  5. Captain Phillips
  6. Blue Jasmine
  7. Her
  8. Inside Llewyn Davis
  9. The Broken Circle Breakdown
  10. The Conjuring

Runners-up: Prisoners, Short Term 12, American Hustle

Nathan's

  1. Before Midnight
  2. Gravity
  3. 12 Years a Slave
  4. Frances Ha
  5. Spring Breakers
  6. Her
  7. World War Z
  8. Prisoners
  9. Blue Jasmine
  10. 20 Feet From Stardom

Runners-up: The Wolf of Wall Street, Captain Phillips, Warm Bodies


2012

images.jpeg
beasts.jpg
Unknown-1.jpeg

Matt's

  1. Zero Dark Thirty
  2. Amour
  3. Beasts of the Southern Wild
  4. The Perks of Being a Wallflower
  5. Moonrise Kingdom
  6. No
  7. Silver Linings Playbook
  8. Ruby Sparks
  9. How to Survive a Plague
  10. The Wise Kids

Runners-up: Django Unchained, Argo, Life of Pi, Lincoln

Nathan's

  1. Beasts of the Southern Wild
  2. Zero Dark Thirty
  3. Amour
  4. Tabu
  5. Magic Mike
  6. Neighboring Sounds
  7. Oslo, August 31st
  8. The Best Exotic Marigold Hotel
  9. Django Unchained
  10. Pitch Perfect

Runner-up: The Master


2011

Unknown-4.jpeg
Unknown-3.jpeg
images-1.jpeg

Matt's

  1. A Separation
  2. Weekend
  3. Beginners
  4. Take Shelter
  5. Moneyball
  6. Bill Cunningham New York
  7. Contagion
  8. Tinker Tailor Soldier Spy
  9. Martha Marcy May Marlene
  10. Rango

Runners-up: Shame, The Tree of Life, Bridesmaids

Nathan's

  1. Bill Cunningham New York
  2. Beginners
  3. Take Shelter
  4. Contagion
  5. Hugo
  6. Weekend
  7. The Skin I Live In
  8. Young Adult
  9. Martha Marcy May Marlene
  10. The Girl With the Dragon Tattoo

Runners-up: Shame, Bridesmaids


2010

images.jpeg
images-1.jpeg
Unknown.jpeg

Matt's

  1. Toy Story 3
  2. The Social Network
  3. I Am Love
  4. Black Swan
  5. The Fighter
  6. Blue Valentine
  7. The Ghost Writer
  8. Inception
  9. How to Train Your Dragon
  10. Another Year

Runners-up: Winter's Bone, Restrepo, The Town

Nathan's

  1. I Am Love
  2. The Social Network
  3. Another Year
  4. Inception
  5. The Fighter
  6. Toy Story 3
  7. The King's Speech
  8. Never Let Me Go
  9. The Kids Are All Right
  10. The Town

Runners-up: Restrepo, Let Me In, Scott Pilgrim vs. the World